Menu

At Casa Maya in St. Augustine, FL, the menu is a vibrant explosion of flavors featuring salads, seafood, and Mexican dishes. This Latinx-owned restaurant offers a diverse range of options, from tacos to quesadillas, all served with fresh ingredients and bold spices. With amenities like outdoor seating, a full bar, and live music, Casa Maya provides a welcoming and festive atmosphere for diners. Customers praise the friendly service and generous portion sizes, with highlights including shrimp and steak tacos, delicious margaritas, and flavorful huevos rancheros. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch spot or a lively dinner experience, Casa Maya promises a culinary journey that will leave you craving more. Visit this gem on Hypolita Street and indulge in a flavor fiesta that will delight your taste buds.

Signature Cocktails House Classics (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Signature Cocktails House Classics (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Casa Mayarita

Must be 21 to purchase. Milagros silver, gala orange liqueur, agave nectar, fresh lime juice and 100% blue agave taquila.

$10.00

Top Shelf Margarita

Must be 21 to purchase. Casa noble silver, grand marnier, fresh orange & lime juice and agave nectar.

$12.00

Smoke and Fire

Must be 21 to purchase. Jalapeno infused tequila, montelobos mezcal, Chile ancho liquor, lime, orange juice, agave, topped with spicy tajin rim and hell-fire bitters.

$12.00

Hibiscus Flowerita

Must be 21 to purchase. Milagros reposed tequila, hibiscus flower tea, grand marnier, hibiscus syrup and sugar rim.

$12.00

Cucumber Jalapeno Margarita

Must be 21 to purchase. Jalapeno infused tequila, cucumber juice, lime juice, gala orange liqueur and agave nectar.

$12.00

Black Widow

Must be 21 to purchase. 1921 reposed tequila, grand marnier, blackberries, lime agave and basil.

$12.00

Mezcal Rita

Must be 21 to purchase. Montelobos mezcal, grand marnier, lime juice, orange juice and agave.

$12.00

Tepache Cilantro

Must be 21 to purchase. Montelobos mezcal, 1921 blanco, lime, cilantro and agave.

$12.00

The Gardener

Must be 21 to purchase. Reyka vodka, cucumber, basil, lime and soda H2O and simple syrup.

$11.00

Mexican 75

Must be 21 to purchase. Champagne, tequila, fresh lime juice and agave.

$10.00

Pina Chicolada

Must be 21 to purchase. Miami rum silver, fresh lime juice, coco Lopez and pineapple juice.

$11.00

Fire Melon

Must be 21 to purchase. Jalapeno infused tequila, fresh watermelon juice, ancho Verde, fresh lime juice and agave.

$11.00

Seasonal Cocktails (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Seasonal Cocktails (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Sangrias (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Sangrias (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Red Sangria

Must be 21 to purchase. Hibiscus flower tea, rum, Merlot cab blend, lime and orange juice, cherry liquor. Our signature recipe that people can't get enough of!

$9.00

White Sangria

Must be 21 to purchase. Homemade peach & pear puree, lime juice, mint, pinot grigio, peach and pear liquor. Topped with cava!

$9.00

Jeio Prosecco Italy

Must be 21 to purchase. Brut style. Fresh citrus. Fresh forward sip.

$12.00

Wine Selections Vino Espumante (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Wine Selections Vino Espumante (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Wine Selections Vino Blanco (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Wine Selections Vino Blanco (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Chemistry Pinot Gris Oregon

Must be 21 to purchase. Crisp & persistent with subtle richness. Citrus. Papaya.

$10.00

Squealing Pig Sauvignon Blanc New Zealand

Must be 21 to purchase. Tropical Marlborough minerality & Texture. Grape fruit, Passion fruit.

$12.00

Hill Family Chardonnay Napa

Must be 21 to purchase. Creamy texture, oak, apple and creme brulee.

$12.00

Lange Pinot Noir Orgon

Must be 21 to purchase. Fruit forward & balanced, currant jam and vanilla spice.

$13.00

Rook Merlot Washington

Must be 21 to purchase. Balanced fine tannins, red & black fruit, orange peel and tobacco.

$11.00

Maal Biutiful Malbec Argentina

Must be 21 to purchase. Integrated acidity & smooth tannins, crushed blackberry and violet.

$12.00

Beringer Knights Valley Cabernet California

Must be 21 to purchase. Soft silky tannins with fine acidity & elegant structure, dark fruit and clove.

$13.00

Wine Selections Vino Rojo (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Wine Selections Vino Rojo (Must be 21 to Purchase)

Buenos Dias

Buenos Dias

Apocalypto Breakfast Torta

Organic eggs with chorizo, cheese, tomato, and crisp bacon slices on fresh baked bread. Topped with avocado & bean spread.

$9.95

Chilaquiles

Crispy corn tortillas cooked with red or green salsa and topped with cheese. Served with sour cream, onion slices and 3 organic eggs. Add steak for an additional charge.

$8.95

Huevos Rancheros

Corn tortilla, vegetarian pinto beans, and three organic eggs. Topped with red or green salsa and quest fresco. Add steak for an additional charge.

$8.95

Vegetarian Omelette

Spinach, mushrooms and Mexican cheese. Topped with fresh avocado and tomato. Served with homemade salsa and vegetarian pinto beans. Add egg whites for an additional charge.

$8.95

Huevos a la Mexicana

Organic eggs scrambled with sweet onions, tomatoes and Serrano peppers. Served with vegetarian beans and salsa.

$7.95

Organic Sweet Potato Pancakes

Pancakes served with fresh strawberries, whipped cream & topped with powdered sugar. Add bacon for an additional charge.

$8.95

Hangover Breakfast

Home fries, peppers, onions and Mexican chorizo. Topped with cheese and eggs. Served with warm corn or flour tortillas.

$10.95

Huevos con Chorizo

Organic eggs scrambled with Mexican chorizo. Served with beans, avocado slices and corn or flour tortillas.

$9.95

Mexican Cuernito

Omelette made to order over a freshly baked Mexican cuernito and topped with a tomato slice. Choice of spinach & cheese or chorizo & cheese. Add bacon and avocado for an additional charge.

$7.50

Huevos Poblanos

Corn tortilla simmered in chocolate Chile sauce. Topped with fried eggs. Served with bread and sliced avocado.

$9.95

Huinic Torta

Slow cooked shredded beef brisket cooked with bell peppers and onions, topped with plantains and avocados.

$9.95

Cochinita Pibil Torta

Mayan Style pit pork, tender chunks of slowly cooked and served with pickled red onions.

$9.95

Xel-Ha Torta

Our Mexican style fish sandwich, topped with lettuce, fresh sliced tomatoes and a cucumber lime cilantro mayo on top.

$9.95

Malinche Torta

Grilled chicken breast, chipotle mayo, fresh sliced tomatoes, onions, avocado and Swiss cheese.

$9.95

Tortas

Tortas

Tacos, Tacos and Y Mas Tacos

Tacos, Tacos and Y Mas Tacos

Carne Asada Taco

Grilled beef skirt steak, cooked and marinated to perfection, topped with avocado. Served with pico de gallo.

$15.95

Campechanos Taco

Enjoy several layers of flavor with our seasoned skirt steak, and pork skin. Topped with homemade avocado sauce.

$15.95

Carnitas Taco

Pork braised until tender and juicy, cooked with Mexican beer. Served with salsa Verde and avocado.

$14.95

Cochinita Taco

Mayan style pit pork, tender chunks of slowly cooked and served with pickled red onions.

$14.95

Al Pastor Taco

Organic chicken strips marinated and sauteed with onions, cilantro and grilled pineapple chunks. Topped with homemade avocado sauce.

$15.95

Pollo Taco

Organic chicken strips marinated and sauteed with onions and peppers, served with avocado.

$13.95

Mahi Taco

Grilled Mahi, pico de gallo, lettuce and homemade chipotle mayo.

$15.95

Fresh Catch Taco

Breaded and fresh local fish, served romaine and topped with chipotle mayo. Served with pico de gallo on the side.

$19.95

Tacos de Pulpo

Octopus sauted with red onion, garlic and olive oil.

$15.95

Shrimp Taco

Sauteed local shrimp, served with lettuce, pico de gallo, avocado slices and our chipotle mayo.

$15.95

Tempeh Taco

Organic tempeh cooked with annatto. Served with pico de gallo, lettuce and topped with avocado slices.

$13.95

Mexican Cheese Quesadilla

$9.95

Mushrooms Quesadilla

$10.95

Spinach Quesadilla

$10.95

Avocado Quesadilla

$10.95

Chicken Quesadilla

$12.95

Beef Quesadilla

$12.95

Shrimp Quesadilla

$13.95

Mushroom Quesadilla

$12.95

Quesadillas

Quesadillas

Soups & Salads

Soups & Salads

Mayan Soup

Vegetarian broth, tomato, white onions, cilantro, avocado and tortilla strips topped with cheese. Served with bread.

$4.25

Black Beans Soup

Fresh black beans cooked daily. Served with a scoop of rice and bread. Topped with cilantro.

$4.25

Yucatan Salad

Organic mixed greens, carrots, tomato, avocado, quest fresco and mango. Served with an organic homemade dressing.

$5.50

Bacalar Salad

Organic spring mix, cucumber, grape tomatoes, quest fresco, tortilla strips, roasted pumpkin seeds. Served with an organic homemade dressing.

$5.50

Salsa and Chips

Authentic secret salsa recipe with 100% baked corn tortillas.

$4.50

Guacamole

Our signature recipe made to order with mashed fresh avocados, onions, cilantro and tomatoes. Served with 100% baked corn tortillas.

$8.50

Cocteles

Your choice of shrimp or octopus with tomato and clam juice cocktail. Ketchup, cucumber, avocado, red onions and cilantro. Served with tortilla chips or saltines.

$12.95

Vuelve a la Vida

Casa maya recipe stock, oysters, shrimp and octopus with tomato and clam juice cocktail. Topped with avocado, cilantro and onions.

$15.95

Ceviche

Your choice of shrimp or octopus. Signature ceviche marinated in citrus juices. Served with 100% baked corn tortillas.

$14.95

1 lb. Peel and Eat Shrimp

Nothing says summer like peel and eat shrimp. Seasoned with signature spices.

$15.00

Oyster Shooters

2 oysters topped with house sangria, paper vodka and lime. Best hangover cure ever.

$5.95

1 lb. Crab Legs

Alaskan snow crabs.

$18.95

White Wine Sauteed Mussels

Sauteed mussels tossed in white wine and roasted garlic. Topped with fresh pico de gallo. Served with garlic toast.

$12.50

Red Sauteed Mussels

Sauteed mussels tossed with our homemade habenero salsa with papers and onions.

$12.50

Steamed Clams

Steamed clams tossed in white wine and roasted garlic. Topped with fresh pico de gallo. Served with garlic toast.

$12.50

Appetizers

Appetizers

Vegetarian Entrees

Vegetarian Entrees

Green Burrito

Spanish rice, organic black beans, cheese sauteed veggies, avocado, all wrapped in a spinach wrap topped with our red salsa and tahini dressing. Add shrimp, tempeh, steak, chicken and mahi for an additional charge.

$16.95

Na-kaab Tempeh

Local tempeh marinated in adobo and achiote served with a fresh veggie medley, organic black beans, spanish rice, and plantains with your choice of corn or flour tortilla.

$16.95

Tikin Xic Fish

Our fresh catch lightly seasoned and marinated with annatto and citrus juices, then wrapped in banana leafs and chargrilled to perfection. Served with Veggies and Potato of the day.

$26.95

Xaman Ha Mahi

Fresh chargrilled mani mani lightly seasoned and broiled then topped with our homemade citrus mango sauce. Served with veggies and potato of the day.

$23.95

Seafood Paella

Saffron scented rice with fresh clams, mussels, strip, scallops, chicken, chorizo, fish, and crab legs all simmered in our seasoned broth and served with bread.

$31.95

Pescado al Guajillo

Fresh catch of the day, sauteed in guajillo sauce, a very mild and sweet pepper, with a bright and tangy flavor cooked with olives and capers served on a bed of rice with spinach and mushrooms.

$26.95

Pakal Shrimp

Shrimp marinated in citrus, guajillo pepper sauce then broiled to perfection. Served over rice with corn relish and balsamic glaze.

$22.95

Seafood

Seafood

Land Entrees

Land Entrees

Cochinita Pibil

A very traditional Yucatan dish. Slow cooked, baked pork marinated in citrus juices and annatto wrapped in banana leaf. Served, topped with a pickled red onion. Accompanied by rice, beans, plantains and your choice of corn or flour tortilla.

$21.95

Ropa Vieja

Slow cooked, shredded beef brisket, simmered with tomatoes, peppers, and onions with a hint of chipotle, served with rice, beans, plantains and your choice of corn or flour tortilla.

$21.95

Hanger Steak

Hanger steak perfectly marinated aged, and chargrilled to perfection. Paired with our homemade chimichurri sauce. Served with potato of the day and asparagus.

$26.95

Carne Asada

Thinly sliced, tender marinated skirt steak served over a bed of rice with black beans with plantains and homemade red salsa on the side.

$23.95

Carnitas

Tender braised pork, marinated with beer and lime. Served with rice, black beans, plantains and your choice corn or flour tortillas.

$21.95

Cordero Asado

Full rack of New Zealand lamb chargrilled. Topped with a chorizo and red onion glaze. Served with mashed potato and veggie of the day.

$29.95

Fajitas

Your choice if steak, shrimp, or chicken, sauteed with bell peppers, onions, and tomatoes. Served with Spanish rice, beans, guacamole, sour cream, and corn or flour tortillas.

$21.95

Pollo al Guajillo

Chicken sauteed in a guajillo pepper sauce served on a bed of rice with spinach, onions, mushrooms, green olives and capers.

$23.95

Mix Fajitas

Your choice if steak, shrimp, or chicken, sauteed with bell peppers, onions, and tomatoes. Served with Spanish rice, beans, guacamole, sour cream, and corn or flour tortillas.

$24.95

Homemade Flan

A sweet egg custard-type dessert. Made with milk, eggs, sugar and vanilla. Topped with caramel.

$5.50

Tres Leches

Infused with a sweet silky mixture using a trio of milks and this cake is 3 times as good.

$6.00

Chocolate Cake

$6.50

Key Lime Pie

$5.75

Caramel Churros

$4.99

Desserts

Desserts